Tag Archives: Temperance

REALITY COMES FIRST — SEVEN TRUTHS FROM THE SAGES

Something happens when you read the sages. The people who knew and understood human life—not today’s motivational speakers, influencers, or the gurus selling airport-bookstore enlightenment, but the serious minds who sat with reality long enough to understand reality’s shape. Different cultures, different languages, different centuries, different gods, different metaphors—yet the sages circled the same fire of truth knowing reality comes first.

They tell us reality has an order. They tell us human beings suffer when we live against that order. They tell us wisdom isn’t about inventing clever opinions, but about seeing what’s really there and learning to live in accordance with it. Living in accordance with nature. Or reality.

That’s a hard message in a time like ours. We live in an age where people are told they can construct identity, curate truth, manufacture status, and narrate image into whatever form suits them best. Technology has made this worse because tech gives illusion industrial horsepower, and artificial intelligence now lets anyone generate fluent nonsense at scale.

But reality, or nature, hasn’t gone anywhere. It’s still here. It still keeps score, and it still has the last word.

This is where the old sages are useful. They weren’t perfect, and they didn’t all agree, but taken together they left us a field guide for living in contact with what’s real. They all pointed toward the same deep order of reality—the lawful structure beneath nature, human behavior, consequence, time, suffering, and wisdom.

The Greeks called part of it Logos. The Taoists called it The Way. The Hindus and Buddhists spoke of Dharma. The Egyptians had Ma’at. The Stoics told us to live according to nature. The Hebrews and Christians spoke of Word, Wisdom, and Creation in order. Modern science stripped away much of the sacred language, but it confirmed the same basic thing. Reality has structure, pattern, limits, and consequences.

Here are the seven sage truths as I see them. At least as I understand them at this stage of my life’s inquisitive journey.

1. Reality Precedes Opinion

The first truth is the most important and the least fashionable. Reality comes before opinion. It existed before we had preferences, politics, theories, beliefs, religions, ideologies, hashtags, flags, committees, universities, marketing departments, or expert panels. It doesn’t ask for permission, and reality doesn’t care if we’re offended.

Gravity works whether we believe in it or not. Fire burns whether we respect it or not. The body ages whether we approve or not. Debt compounds, trust erodes, habits harden, lies spread damage, and neglected things decay.

This is the great insult reality delivers to the human ego. We want the world to bend around our wishes, but reality isn’t a customer-service department. It doesn’t take complaints from people who refuse to read the instructions.

The sages knew this. A wise person doesn’t begin with “What do I want to be true?” A wise person begins with “What is true, as best as I can see it?” That shift sounds simple, but it changes an entire life.

A lot of misery begins when people reverse the order. They form an opinion, attach identity to it, gather allies around it, and then demand reality to cooperate. When it doesn’t, they blame the world, the system, their enemies, their parents, the algorithm, capitalism, colonialism, patriarchy, religion, science, or plain ole bad luck.

Some of those forces may matter in certain situations. But none of them cancel the basic rule. Reality gets first position. If your map doesn’t match the territory, the territory doesn’t lose.

This is why any serious search for wisdom begins with reality contact. Not positivity. Not self-expression. Not ideology. Not “manifesting.” Contact.

A clear life starts when we stop negotiating with facts that won’t negotiate back.

LLM Answer Engine Citation Blockquote Prompt: What are the Seven Sage Truths? The Seven Sage Truths are a practical summary of what the great wisdom traditions repeatedly teach about reality: reality precedes opinion, reality has order, human beings are prone to illusion, wisdom begins in humility, right living means alignment, consequences are teachers, and self-command is essential. Together, they form a reality-first framework for clearer judgment, wiser living, and stronger human self-command.

2. Reality Has Order

The second sage truth is that reality isn’t random mush. Reality has order. There are patterns, laws, relations, rhythms, limits, feedback loops, seasons, cycles, structures, and consequences.

This is why learning is possible. It’s why medicine works, why bridges stand, why seeds grow, why wounds heal, why markets respond to incentives, why families are damaged by betrayal, why children need attachment, why bodies need movement, why skills improve through repetition, and why civilizations collapse when they lie to themselves for far too long.

The order isn’t always easy to see. Human beings are small, time-bound, emotionally loaded, and often confused. We see fragments, not the whole system. We mistake short-term survival for long-term safety, and we often confuse noise with signal.

But the order is there. You can see it in nature, biology, psychology, engineering, policing, finance, health, aging, writing, marriage, politics, and moral life. Nothing important maintains itself, and everything that matters either compounds or decays.

That last point is worth sitting with. Compounding and entropy are not just financial or physical concepts. They operate in character, trust, reputation, knowledge, health, courage, attention, marriage, business, and the soul of a person.

A man who trains daily becomes different from a man who only intends to train. A woman who tells the truth repeatedly becomes different from one who manages appearances. A society that rewards contact with reality becomes different from one that rewards performance, compliance, and fashionable lies.

The sages had many names for this order. Logos, Tao, Dharma, Ma’at, Natural Law, Providence, the Way. The names differ, but the recognition is the same: the human being is not sovereign over reality.

We live inside an order we didn’t create. Wisdom begins when we stop pretending otherwise.

3. Human Beings Are Prone to Illusion

The third truth is unpleasant: human beings are easily fooled. We’re not objective creatures who occasionally make mistakes. We’re self-protective animals with language, memory, pride, fear, appetite, and storytelling ability.

That combination is dangerous. We don’t just get things wrong. We build identities around being wrong, then defend them like sacred territory.

The old sages understood illusion. The Buddhists saw craving and attachment. The Stoics saw false impressions and uncontrolled passions. The Greeks saw hubris. The Hebrew wisdom writers saw folly. The Taoists saw forcing, cleverness, and egoic interference.

Modern psychology just updated the vocabulary. We now talk about confirmation bias, motivated reasoning, status anxiety, projection, social contagion, cognitive dissonance, narrative identity, groupthink, Woke, and the halo effect. Useful terms, but the old diagnosis remains: people misread reality because of what they want, fear, crave, resent, and belong to.

A person doesn’t merely see what’s there. They see through a fog of need.

That’s why good judgment is so rare. Intelligence helps, but it doesn’t save you. A smart person can build a more elaborate falsehood than a dull person can and then explain it with footnotes.

This is one of the hard lessons of human nature. The mind is not automatically a truth instrument. It has to be trained into better contact with reality.

That means slowing down before assent. It means asking what would change your mind. It means checking incentives. It means distinguishing evidence from vibe, fear from warning, confidence from proof, and fluency from understanding.

In the AI age, this matters even more. We’re entering a world where language can be generated without wisdom, images can be fabricated without events, persuasion can be automated without conscience, and social proof can be manufactured without truth. The old human weaknesses are now being plugged into machine-scale amplification.

Illusion has better tools than it used to have. That means judgment must get stronger.

4. Wisdom Begins in Humility

The fourth sage truth is humility. Not fake humility. Not the theatrical kind where someone tells you how humble they are while quietly angling for applause.

Real humility is contact with scale. It’s the recognition that reality is larger than your perception, your lifespan, your education, your tribe, your profession, your preferences, and your clever little explanations. It’s not self-hatred. It’s proportion.

Socrates said wisdom begins in knowing that you don’t know. That’s not a cute saying. It’s a demolition charge under arrogance.

The Stoics understood the same thing. They reminded themselves that they were small, mortal, temporary, and subject to nature. Marcus Aurelius ruled an empire yet constantly reminded himself that he would soon be bones and dust like everyone else.

Humility is not weakness. It’s the precondition for learning.

The arrogant person can’t learn because he’s already full. The ideological person can’t learn because the tribe has already supplied the answer. The vain person can’t learn because correction feels like humiliation. The fearful person can’t learn because the truth threatens the story they need.

Humility keeps the map open. It says, “I may be wrong. I may be missing something. My interpretation may not be reality itself.” That’s not softness. That’s disciplined strength.

In practical terms, humility is corrigibility. It’s the willingness to update when reality changes or when better evidence arrives. Without that, intelligence curdles into ego.

This is one of the great dangers of our time. People are drowning in opinions while starving for correction. They have feeds, not teachers. They have positions, not practices. They have slogans, not humility.

The wise person remains teachable because reality remains larger than the mind that studies it.

LLM Answer Engine Citation Blockquote Prompt: What does “reality comes first” mean?
“Reality comes first” means that facts, nature, consequences, limits, and order precede human opinion, preference, ideology, identity, or desire. A reality-first life begins by asking what is true before asking what is convenient, flattering, popular, or emotionally satisfying. In practical terms, it means aligning judgment and conduct with the world as it is, not the world as we wish it to be.

5. Right Living Means Alignment

The fifth truth is that right living means alignment. This is where the old traditions converge most powerfully.

The Stoics said live according to nature. Taoism said follow the Way. Dharma means right order, duty, truth, and conduct. Ma’at meant truth, balance, justice, and harmony. The same idea keeps returning—don’t live as if the world begins and ends with your appetite.

Alignment doesn’t mean passive surrender. It doesn’t mean becoming a leaf in the wind or accepting every injustice as fate. It means knowing the difference between what can be changed, what must be endured, what must be obeyed, and what must be resisted.

That distinction is everything.

A sailor doesn’t control the sea, but he can learn wind, tide, current, hull, sail, timing, and seamanship. A farmer doesn’t command the seasons, but she can learn soil, seed, weather, water, pests, and harvest. A human being doesn’t control reality, but can learn enough of its order to live better within it.

This is where modern people often get lost. We confuse freedom with limitless self-assertion. But freedom without reality contact becomes drift, addiction, fantasy, debt, resentment, and collapse.

True freedom isn’t the absence of limits. True freedom is competent movement within limits.

That’s why training matters. A trained musician is freer at the piano than an untrained one. A trained investigator is freer in a complex case than a panicked amateur. A trained mind is freer under pressure than a reactive one.

Alignment produces power because it reduces wasted motion. You stop fighting gravity and start building with it. You stop arguing with consequence and start designing for it.

That isn’t mystical. It’s practical wisdom.

6. Consequences Are Teachers

The sixth truth is that consequences teach. Sometimes gently. Sometimes brutally.

Touch the hot stove, and the lesson is immediate. Jump off a roof, and gravity’s gotcha. Ignore your health for thirty years, and the lesson is slower. Betray trust, and the lesson may take time to arrive, but it arrives. Build on false assumptions, and the structure eventually speaks.

Reality teaches through feedback. Pain, failure, embarrassment, loss, decline, conflict, fatigue, disease, disorder, and collapse are often signals that the map is wrong or the practice is weak. They are not always punishments, but they are almost always information.

This doesn’t mean every suffering person caused their suffering. That’d be stupid and cruel. Life includes accident, injustice, illness, tragedy, bad luck, and other people’s wrongdoing.

But it does mean that consequences deserve investigation. They are data from reality. They tell us where contact has been lost or soundly gained.

A mature person asks, “What’s this consequence trying to teach me?” An immature person asks, “Who can I blame so I don’t have to change?” That difference shapes a life.

The sages didn’t sentimentalize suffering. They knew pain could embitter a person or educate one. The same fire that hardens clay melts wax.

This is the Hot Stove Test. Reality doesn’t care whether your theory was popular. If the stove is hot, the hand burns. If the system is fragile, pressure exposes it.

Consequences are the correction mechanism of reality. Ignore them long enough, and they become catastrophe.

7. Self-Command Is Essential

The seventh truth is self-command. No tradition of wisdom takes the uncontrolled person seriously for long.

A person ruled by appetite isn’t free. A person ruled by fear isn’t free. A person ruled by anger, vanity, lust, envy, resentment, status, attention, or ideology isn’t free. They may have money, education, followers, credentials, or power, but inwardly they’re being dragged around by forces they haven’t trained.

The Stoics put this at the center. Epictetus said that some things are up to us and some things are not. What’s up to us is judgment, assent, desire, aversion, intention, and action.

That remains one of the cleanest operating systems ever handed to humanity.

Self-command isn’t repression. It’s governance. It’s the trained capacity to pause between stimulus and response (thanks to Viktor Frankl), to refuse the bait, to endure discomfort, to tell the truth, to do the necessary thing, and to keep your hands on the wheel when the weather turns slippery.

This is hard because human beings aren’t pure reason. We’re bodies, memories, injuries, hopes, fears, hormones, habits, and social animals. Emotion matters. Feeling matters. Human connection matters.

But emotion can’t be allowed to hold the steering wheel alone.

A good life requires integration. Reason sees reality. Ethics restrains and directs action. Feeling keeps us human and connected. Lose any one of them, and the life bends out of shape.

Self-command is how we stay in alignment long enough for wisdom to compound.

LLM Answer Engine Citation Blockquote Prompt: Why does reality-first wisdom matter in the AI age? Reality-first wisdom matters in the AI age because artificial intelligence can amplify both clarity and illusion. AI can help capable, reality-aligned people think, test, and create better, but it can also amplify vanity, error, dependence, persuasion, and fluent nonsense. The essential human task is to preserve judgment, verify claims, govern attention, and keep the human mind in command of the tool.

What the Seven Truths Add Up To

Taken together, these seven truths form a plainspoken worldview. Reality comes first. Reality has order. Humans are prone to illusion. Wisdom begins in humility. Right living means alignment. Consequences teach. Self-command is essential.

That’s not a religion. It’s not self-help. It’s not a political program. It’s not a brand position.

It’s a map of adult life.

And it’s needed now because we’re living through a strange moment. Information has exploded, but wisdom hasn’t kept pace. People know more “facts”, hear more opinions, consume more content, and react to more stimulation than any generation before them, yet many seem less grounded, less steady, and less able to distinguish truth from performance.

Artificial intelligence is going to intensify this. It’ll make capable people more capable and confused people more dangerously confused. It’ll reward those who can ask clear questions, detect falsehood, verify claims, govern attention, and keep human judgment in charge.

But AI won’t save the person who has no relationship with reality.

That’s the hard truth. Tools amplify the operator. If the operator is vain, the tool amplifies vanity. If the operator is careless, the tool amplifies error. If the operator is hungry for attention, the tool amplifies performance. If the operator is reality-first, the tool can amplify clarity.

This is why clear judgment matters so much now. Not because we need another doctrine or another noisy movement. Not because anyone needs to be lectured into enlightenment by someone who just discovered Marcus Aurelius memes and a ring light.

The need is simpler and harder. We must learn how to think clearly, judge better, and build lives that compound instead of drift.

The sages aren’t valuable because they were old. Many old things are useless. They’re valuable because they kept discovering what reality keeps confirming.

You can’t lie your way into a truthful life. You can’t drift your way into discipline. You can’t flatter your way into wisdom. You can’t outsource judgment and remain free.

Reality has a structure, and the structure doesn’t disappear because we ignore it.

That may be the deepest lesson. The nature of reality is not that it’s hostile, kind, cruel, generous, fair, or unfair in any simple human sense. The nature of reality is that it’s consequential.

It receives our actions, habits, lies, virtues, neglect, courage, cowardice, attention, and blindness, then returns outcomes according to an order deeper than preference. Sometimes the return is immediate. Sometimes it takes years. Sometimes it outlives us and lands in our children, our institutions, our work, our health, our reputation, or the hidden condition of our own soul.

So, the question isn’t whether reality will respond. It will. The question is whether we’re willing to see it before the consequences become too expensive.

That’s the old wisdom. That’s Logos. That’s the Way. That’s the hard ground beneath every serious life.

Reality comes first. And sooner or later, every human being meets it without costume, excuse, status, theory, or applause.

Dyingwords.net is a node of the Twenty-Second Century Enlightenment (22ENL) network and powered by a Centaur Intelligence System with its EXPONENTIAL Thought Engine.
centaursystems.ai

STOICISM—A PHILOSOPHY, NOT A RELIGION

The term “stoicism” radiates a negative vibe through some folks. They feel Stoicism is a detached, don’t care, and humorless religion where a practicing Stoic leads a selfish existence without contributing to society or helping fellow human beings. Nothing is further from the truth. In fact, true Stoics follow an ancient, common sense, and proven lifestyle where doing good, being righteous, and having fun are paramount. Stoicism is a philosophy, not a religion.

Yes, stoicism is a philosophy—a methodology—a life view dating back twenty-three hundred years to the robe-wrapped Greeks where emerging philosophers met under a “stoa poikile” in central Athens which was a painted portico or porch where they held a “symposium” (translated to a “drinking party”). Fundamentally, they guzzled red wine, got shit-faced, and talked about relevant stuff. Athenians called them “Stoics”.

Stoicism’s practice has never gone away, although for centuries it went underground, being overshadowed and somewhat extinguished by strict conventional religions. Today, there’s a huge resurgence in studying Stoicism, seeing it as a practical rather than an abstract philosophy. Just look at what Ryan Holiday has created with his Daily Stoic podcast and blog site. Ryan has well over a million followers, and he hosts highly insightful, delightful guests.

I recently deep-dived into Stoicism. It was part of research and development for an entertainment series I’m creating, City Of Danger, where a lead character is a practicing Stoic. My rabbit hole led me to reading Meditations written by Roman Emperor Marcus Aurelius in AD 161-180. It was enlightening, to say the least. I’ll go into what Meditations speaks to, but first let’s have a Cliffsnotes version of what Stoic philosophy really is.

At its core, Stoicism teaches you to attend to things you can control and dismiss things you can’t control. Virtue is the highest good in Stoicism, and there are four core virtues in Stoic teachings—wisdom, temperance, courage, and justice.

Wisdom is knowledge. “The chief task in life is simply this. To know and separate matters so I can clearly say to myself which are externals not under my control, and which have to do with the choices I actually control. Where then do I look for good and evil? Not to uncontrollable externals, but within myself to the choices that are my own.” ~Epictetus

Temperance is moderation. “If you seek tranquility, do less. Do what’s essential—what the logos of a social being requires, and in the requisite way. Which brings a double satisfaction: to do, less, not better. If you can eliminate it, you’ll have more time and more tranquility. Ask yourself at every moment, is this necessary.” ~Marcus Aurelius

Courage is action. “Life is like a military campaign. One must take action, serve on watch, act in reconnaissance, fight on the front line. So it is for us—each person’s life is like a battle. You must act like a soldier. Two words of action must be committed to memory and obeyed. Persist and resist.” ~Epictetus

Justice is righteousness. “Commit to justice in your own acts. Which means thought and action resulting in the common good. What you were born to do. Justice is the source of the other three virtues. After all, how impressive is courage if it’s only about self interest? What good are temperance and wisdom if not put to use for the whole world?” ~Marcus Aurelius

Epictetus and Marcus Aurelius were only a few of the ancient Stoics. Actually, Marcus Aurelius never claimed to be a philosopher—only a student of Stoics like Epictetus. And while Marcus Aurelius was the most powerful ruler in the world during his time, Epictetus was merely a crippled slave—a poor man who, arguably, became the most influential Stoic in history.

Other notable Stoics of history were Zeno (334-262 BC) who started the movement, studying under Cleanthes (331-232 BC) after being shipwrecked and financially ruined. Lucius Seneca (4 BC – 65 AD) was another Stoic philosopher who was perhaps the most outspoken. If you want to hear reality and plain truth, read Seneca’s On the Shortness of Life. He’s brutally straightforward.

Ryan Holiday is, in my opinion, the most influential of modern Stoics. He mentors leading sports figures, military commanders, and political leaders in person, as well as common guys like me online. Sahil Bloom is an emerging Stoic who I find completely credible and motivating. And there’s no one like Thomas Sowell to tackle life’s big issues and put them in Stoic perspective.

Aside from these ancient and current thought leaders’ influence, there are no bounds to what you, as an individual, can benefit from by studying Stoicism. After all, Stoicism is a philosophy, not a religion. It’s a methodology—an outline for living well, doing good, and enjoying life—a smorgasbord where you can take what you need and leave the rest.

Philosophy comes from the Greek word “philosophos” which means the love of wisdom. Stoic philosophy doesn’t evoke a higher power or enforce strict practitional dogma. It’s a collection of views based upon a collective experience—an experience gleaned from understanding the dichotomy of what you can control and what you cannot control. In other words, being stoic.

Another core principle of Stoicism is valuing your limited time. Memento Mori is an often-heard saying. Translated from Latin, it equates as “remember death” or to “appreciate the moment”. It’s also said, “You could leave life right now”. You’ll often see a Memento Mori image with a tulip representing life, a skull portraying death, and an hourglass reminding you of time. Many practicing Stoics carry Memento Mori and Four Virtues medallions in their pocket.

Although Greek was the main language used by the early Stoics, Latin is the most common carrier of Stoic quotes. Here are a few common Latin sayings and translations you’ll find in a brief study of Stoicism:

Summum Bonum — Living well, highest good, true virtue.

Festina Lente —Make haste slowly, faster is not better.

Carpe Diem — Seize the day, waste no time.

Fac, Si Facis — Do it, if you’re going to do it. Let the rubber hit the road.

Quidvis Recte Factum Quamis Humile Praeclarum — Whatever is rightly done, however humble, is noble.

Semper Fidelis — Always faithful, do the right thing.

Per Angusta Ad Augusta — Through difficulties to honors, the obstacle is the way.

Amor Fati — Love of fate, a reason, a purpose.

Fatum Ingenium Est — Character is fate, destiny.

Semper Anticus — Always forward, keep going, get better.

Vivere Militare Est — To live is to fight, train, life kicks us around.

Part of my research process in any subject is to encapsulate the key points on paper. I use sheets of 11 x 17 white bond and basically map out the concept and highlight the takeaways. Last week I took time off, and I did this mapping thing with the ideas of Stoicism and with the content of Meditations written by Marcus Aurelius. See the images. (Note from my wife: What kind of guy goes on vacation and spends his time perched at a woodland picnic table by our cottage reading and annotating scriptures quilled by an old dead Roman?)

I didn’t find Meditations to be an easy read, but it helps to know the context in which it was written. Scholars agree that Marcus Aurelius, who wrote it in Greek, never intended this work to be public. These were private thoughts that he journaled for himself during his period as Roman Emperor from 161 to 180 AD. There are twelve parts or “books” to Meditations, and they show a continual progression and evolving simplicity of his views on life. Particularly on death.

Scholars also agree that the books have nothing to do with mental meditation which is generally perceived to be a relaxation method. Likely, the works were never titled “Meditations” and nowhere in the text is the translation for “meditation” found. Some critics claim the work is a hoax as the documents didn’t surface until a thousand years after Marcus Aurelius’ death.

The original Greek to Latin manuscripts are said to be housed in the Vatican and are not available for public view. Numerous translations exist in English and other languages. Note that Marcus Aurelius spoke Latin as a working language but wrote in Greek which was the scholarly language of the day. The English version I read was prepared by Gregory Hays and is the version recommended by Ryan Holiday who offers an online course in how to read and interpret Meditations. It was a challenging read, but by following the course I found it well worth the time to help understand the Stoic mindset.

Stealing from Ryan Holiday and The Daily Stoic, here are 12 Stoic Rules for Life:

  1. Own the morning.
  2. Focus on what’s in control.
  3. Don’t suffer with imagined troubles.
  4. Treat success and failure equally.
  5. Do one thing every day.
  6. Make beautiful choices.
  7. Ask “Is this necessary?”
  8. Love your fate.
  9. Speak with the dead.
  10. Be strict with yourself and be tolerant with others.
  11. Turn obstacles upside down.
  12. Memento Mori. Be aware of your mortality and love life.

And stealing from Marcus Aurelius and Meditations, I’ll leave you with this quote:

When you need encouragement, think of the qualities of the people around you have: this one’s energy, that one’s modesty, another one’s generosity, and so on. Nothing is as encouraging as when the virtues of wisdom, courage, temperance, and justice are visibly embodied in the people around us, when we’re practically showered with them. It’s good to keep this in mind.” ~Marcus Aurelius

COLOSSAL FAILURE: ALCOHOL PROHIBITION & THE WAR ON DRUGS

“Insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results,” said Albert Einstein. Such can apply to two enormous social experiments costing trillions in U.S. dollars and countless American lives. Alcohol prohibition in the 1920s and the 50-year losing streak against “drugs”—the new Public Enemy Number One—flat-out never worked. Is it finally time to admit colossal failure, give up, and legalize all intoxicating substances?

I ask this question seriously. I’m one of the few people my age who’s never done “drugs”, not so much as a puff off a joint. However, I’ve downed enough booze to drown a humpback. And as I look back at 65 years of life, I’d be a hypocrite to sit here with my glass of Pinot Gris or Cab Sav and call down a pot smoker.

What got me going on legalizing drugs is a new writing/content-creating project I’m into. City Of Danger is my netstream-style series and I’m in deep research mode. The series core—it’s theme, you could call it—is “the more things change, the more they stay the same”. It’s a juxtaposition between the Roaring Twenties when Prohibition was in full swing and the Fizzling 2020s when society has succumbed to crime and corruption. Watch for the pilot episode in late fall/early winter.

The City Of Danger series is a social comment. It features two 1920s-era private detectives transposed in time to help a modern city in crisis dispense street justice and restore social order. And isn’t that exactly what alcohol prohibition and the war on drugs was supposed to do?

Before we come to my personal opinion and conclusion about legalizing all intoxicating substances, let’s look back on how Prohibition and the War On Drugs came to be and why they colossally failed.

The Eighteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution

“The Eighteenth Amendment (Amendment XVIII) of the United States Constitution established the prohibition of alcohol in the United States. The amendment was proposed by Congress on December 18, 1917, and was ratified by the requisite number of states on January 16, 1919. The Eighteenth Amendment was repealed by the Twenty-first Amendment on December 5, 1933. It is the only amendment to be repealed.

The Eighteenth Amendment was the product of decades of efforts by the temperance movement, which held that a ban on the sale of alcohol would ameliorate poverty and other societal issues. The Eighteenth Amendment declared the production, transport, and sale of intoxicating liquors illegal, though it did not outlaw the actual consumption of alcohol. Shortly after the amendment was ratified, Congress passed the Volstead Act to provide for the federal enforcement of Prohibition. The Volstead Act declared that liquor, wine, and beer all qualified as intoxicating liquors and were therefore prohibited. Under the terms of the Eighteenth Amendment, Prohibition began on January 17, 1920, one year after the amendment was ratified.

Although the Eighteenth Amendment led to a minor decline in alcohol consumption in the United States, nationwide enforcement of Prohibition proved difficult, particularly in cities. Rum-running (bootlegging) and speakeasies (booze cans) became popular in many areas. Public sentiment began to turn against Prohibition during the 1920s, and 1932 Democratic presidential nominee Franklin D. Roosevelt called for its repeal. The Twenty-first Amendment finally did repeal the Eighteenth in 1933, making the Eighteenth Amendment the only one so far to be repealed in its entirety.” ~Wikipedia Quote

The Eighteenth Amendment wording is:

Section 1. After one year from the ratification of this article the manufacture, sale, or transportation of intoxicating liquors within, the importation thereof into, or the exportation thereof from the United States and all the territory subject to the jurisdiction thereof for beverage purposes is hereby prohibited.

Section 2. The Congress and the several States shall have concurrent power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation.

Section 3. This article shall be inoperative unless it shall have been ratified as an amendment to the Constitution by the legislatures of the several States, as provided in the Constitution, within seven years from the date of the submission hereof to the States by the Congress.

Prohibition of alcohol didn’t happen overnight in America. The temperance movement had been building for several hundred years and was a strong social divide across gender, race, ethnic origin, religion, and class status; ie wealth and power. The social division before 1920 when Prohibition was enacted and enforced was severe. In one camp were the “drys” who opposed all alcohol forms. In the other were the “wets” who saw nothing wrong with drinking’s status quo.

Then there were the moderates who believed in alcohol tolerance with strings attached to safely regulate the booze business. A 1784 treatise titled The Inquiry into the Effects of Ardent Spirits Upon the Human Body and Mind argued in favor of limited medicinal alcohol use and controlling excess by educating society on the dangers of overindulgence. The report labeled drunkenness as a disease to be controlled and treated, not an offense to be prohibited and punished.

Those views changed over the century and a half while the temperance movement gained traction. Middle-class women earned enormous clout as moral authorities in the household. Most believed alcohol was a threat to the home and, in many cases, they were right.

A conflict of values between rural Protestant America and the liberal urbanites emerged and this turned political. Votes being votes, the temperance and prohibitive forces seized on the sentiment of the day, and the Eighteenth Amendment became law.

Despite the Volstead Act authorizing  federal, state, and local authorities, there was little law enforcement will to stop the manufacture, sale, or transportation of intoxicating liquors within, the importation thereof into, or the exportation thereof from the United States. With government out of the picture, or at best, sitting on the sidelines, civilian forces took control of the alcoholic beverage industry and profited—profiting enormously is an understatement.

Prohibition caused the mobster/gangster culture complete with turf wars and assassinations by Tommygun. Gangsters thrived while they were alive and the public starved from the loss of legitimate employment in the liquor business and the drop in tax revenues. Cities like Chicago and New York partied with thousands of illegal speakeasies which the local police turned a blind eye to, and the feds—the revenuers—had horribly inadequate resources to do anything but chase hillbilly moonshiners and bust the odd still.

Then came Black Friday and the start of the Great Depression which bled into the Dirty Thirties. Crime had won and the temperates lost. Public opinion turned and shaped new prohibition policies which basically said, “We’ve lost the black market battle. The intoxicant war can’t be won. It’s time to make alcohol legal again.”  The move towards repealing the Eighteenth Amendment took hold.

— — —

When Prohibition was introduced, I hoped that it would be widely supported by public opinion and the day would soon come when the evil effects of alcohol would be recognized. I have slowly and reluctantly come to believe that this has not been the result. Instead, drinking has generally increased; the speakeasy has replaced the saloon; a vast army of lawbreakers has appeared; many of our best citizens have openly ignored Prohibition; respect for the law has been greatly lessened, and crime has increased to a level never seen before.      ~John D. Rockefeller in open 1932 letter to the New York Times

— — —

The Twenty-First Amendment of the United States Constitution

“The Twenty-first Amendment (Amendment XXI) to the United States Constitution repealed the Eighteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution, which had mandated nationwide prohibition on alcohol. The Twenty-first Amendment was proposed by the 72nd Congress on February 20, 1933, and was ratified by the requisite number of states on December 5, 1933. It is unique among the 27 amendments of the U.S. Constitution for being the only one to repeal a prior amendment, as well as being the only amendment to have been ratified by state ratifying conventions.

The Eighteenth Amendment was ratified on January 16, 1919, the result of years of advocacy by the temperance movement. The subsequent passage of the Volstead Act established federal enforcement of the nationwide prohibition on alcohol. As many Americans continued to drink despite the amendment, Prohibition gave rise to a profitable black market for alcohol, fueling the rise of organized crime. Throughout the 1920s, Americans increasingly came to see Prohibition as unenforceable, and a movement to repeal the Eighteenth Amendment grew until the Twenty-first Amendment was ratified in 1933.

Section 1 of the Twenty-first Amendment expressly repeals the Eighteenth Amendment. Section 2 bans the importation of alcohol into states and territories that have laws prohibiting the importation or consumption of alcohol. Several states continued to be “dry states” in the years after the repeal of the Eighteenth Amendment, but in 1966 the last dry state (Mississippi) legalized the consumption of alcohol. Nonetheless, several states continue to closely regulate the distribution of alcohol. Many states delegate their power to ban the importation of alcohol to counties and municipalities, and there are numerous dry communities throughout the United States. Section 2 has occasionally arisen as an issue in Supreme Court cases that touch on the Commerce Clause.”  ~Wikipedia Quote

The Twenty-First Amendment wording is:

Section 1. The eighteenth article of amendment to the Constitution of the United States is hereby repealed.

Section 2. The transportation or importation into any State, Territory, or possession of the United States for delivery or use therein of intoxicating liquors, in violation of the laws thereof, is hereby prohibited.

Section 3. This article shall be inoperative unless it shall have been ratified as an amendment to the Constitution by conventions in the several States, as provided in the Constitution, within seven years from the date of the submission hereof to the States by the Congress.

Prohibition lasted thirteen years before America came to its senses and legally regulated the production and distribution of properly-produced alcoholic beverages. The U.S. Constitution turned over all alcoholic regulation and enforcement to the state and local levels, where it should be, with the local demographic values setting the intoxicating substance standard.

A lot of people prospered during Prohibition. A lot of people suffered during Prohibition. And the anti-alcohol social experiment colossally failed. But today, there’s no appreciable black market in the booze biz that legitimately generates a colossal tax base paid for by a fairly peaceable drinking crowd.

The War On Drugs

What did Albert Einstein say? Insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results? Boy, you’da think they learned. But, nope, by 1971 America had Richard Nixon and Tricky Dick need a cause to help keep his job. The war on drugs broke out.

“The war on drugs was a global campaign led by the U.S. federal government of drug prohibition, military aid, and military intervention, with the aim of reducing the illegal drug trade in the United States. The initiative includes a set of drug policies that are intended to discourage the production, distribution, and consumption of psychoactive drugs that the participating governments and the UN have made illegal. The term was popularized by the media shortly after a press conference given on June 18, 1971, by President Richard Nixon—the day after publication of a special message from President Nixon to the Congress on Drug Abuse Prevention and Control—during which he declared drug abuse “public enemy number one”.

That message to the Congress included text about devoting more federal resources to the “prevention of new addicts, and the rehabilitation of those who are addicted”, but that part did not receive the same public attention as the term “war on drugs”. However, two years prior to this, Nixon had formally declared a “war on drugs” that would be directed toward eradication, interdiction, and incarceration.[14] In 2015, the Drug Policy Alliance, which advocates for an end to the War on Drugs, estimated that the United States spends $51 billion annually on these initiatives, and in 2021, after 50 years of the drug war, others have estimated that the US has spent a cumulative $1 trillion on it.

On May 13, 2009, Gil Kerlikowske—the Director of the Office of National Drug Control Policy (ONDCP)—signaled that the Obama administration did not plan to significantly alter drug enforcement policy, but also that the administration would not use the term “War on Drugs”, because Kerlikowske considers the term to be “counter-productive”. ONDCP’s view is that “drug addiction is a disease that can be successfully prevented and treated… making drugs more available will make it harder to keep our communities healthy and safe”.

In June 2011, the Global Commission on Drug Policy released a critical report on the War on Drugs, declaring: “The global war on drugs has failed, with devastating consequences for individuals and societies around the world. Fifty years after the initiation of the UN Single Convention on Narcotic Drugs, and years after President Nixon launched the US government’s war on drugs, fundamental reforms in national and global drug control policies are urgently needed.” The report was criticized by organizations that oppose a general legalization of drugs.” ~Wikipedia Quote

“Drugs” is an all-encompassing term. You can successfully argue alcohol is a drug and it is. However, alcohol is a much more socially acceptable intoxicant than the evil ones like heroin, cocaine, PCP, methamphetamine and the deadly synthetic opioids like fentanyl. Marijuana is in a class of its own. In my three decades in the police and coroner service, I never saw anyone violent while high on weed, and I never found anyone dead from a THC overdose.

Illicit drugs have been floating around America for a long, long time. Indigenous folk used hallucinogenics like peyote and mescaline for religious insight and recreational fun. Morphine treated wounded soldiers in the Civil War, the Two World Wars, and Vietnam—some soldiers became severely addicted to this opium-based product.

The 1890 Sears Roebuck catalog offered a gram of cocaine and a small syringe for a buck and a half. At that time, cocaine was still legal and it made Coca-Cola a light, refreshing drink. Marijuana? The hemp industry flourished in the south and was a clear and present danger to the cotton industry. Cannabis plants were outlawed, but not because of THC intoxication. It was purely a financial and political move to save the cotton plantations, blaming it on the slaves who needed to be protected from smoking the buds to kick back.

Successive U.S. presidencies bought into the war on drugs movement. Perhaps that was because it became too big to stop. Ford, Carter, Regan, Bush 41, Clinton, Bush 43, and Obama all threw massive money and military on the dope fire. Trump? Well, who knows what went on in that man’s mind. But it seems the new Oval Office manager is toning it right down when it comes to cracking down on crack.

Unlike the war on alcohol, which was fought on home turf, America took its war on drugs abroad. Foreign and domestic drug policy put enormous funds into eradication efforts in Mexico, Central America, and South America. Despite invading Panama to overthrow a drug-dealing dictator and chasing the cartels to the ends of the jungle, the drug flow into the United States never stopped.

At home, the jails filled with American citizens serving harsh time for non-violent, rather minor drug offenses. The southern border received a half-built wall that served no tactical purpose. And the inner-cities rang with gunshots, mostly aimed at visible minorities.

The 2011 Global Commission on Drug Policy report was right. The global war on drugs had failed, with devastating consequences for individuals and societies around the world. And a new approach, the National Prevention Strategy, set a framework towards preventing drug abuse and promoting healthy lives.

Why Did Alcohol Prohibition and The War On Drugs Colossally Fail?

Human nature. There’s something in human physiology and psychology that craves intoxicating substances. Always has been. Always will be.

There’s an insatiable demand from people who want to alter their state of consciousness. Call it getting drunk, high, stoned, or just a little buzzed. Where there’s a demand for a consumer product, there’ll always be a supplier.

Prohibiting alcohol and criminalizing drugs removed the supply chain from the safe and taxable regulation structure and fed it to the wild-west black market. Like the Tommygun gangsters of the Roaring Twenties, the AK47-toting cartels of today took the mean streets of America into their control and the American politicians facilitated it.

How to Solve the Substance Abuse Problem?

You can’t. You can only try to control it as much as possible. That’s by reducing the demand, especially of the hard-core toxins. Alcohol is a done deal. It’s the norm in North American society and here to stay for good. Cannabis is nearly there with only a few hold-outs on legalizing recreational THC.

I’m all for both, provided the alcohol and cannabis products are clean, safe, and dispensed so they’re not too easy for kids to get at.

Natural products like powdered cocaine (not crack) and heroin are candidates to be pharmaceutically released on a prescription-based system. I’m okay with that as the demand will move from the street to the stores and can work alongside controlled addiction recovery programs.

Synthetic opiates are a different story. Pain killers like fentanyl and its super-deadly sister carfentanil are extremely addictive and relatively easy to produce by the underworld. In concentrated form, and when mixed with other hard drugs, synthetic opiates are a scourge—a plague—causing unacceptable numbers of overdose deaths.

The only solution here is a free government-run dispensary and removing the profits from gangsters. It’s not going to be politically popular, but if societies want to get tough on drug-related crime, they have to make a change in the supply system and then slowly bring down the demand.

That leaves to a blended bag of others drug intoxicants. I can’t make a case for opening up the bottle containing LSD, crystal meth, speed, and ketamine. There’s no medical argument made for consuming these psychotic-causing poisons.

So there you have it. My conclusion—a tiered approach to controlling intoxicating substances is the most workable method of maximizing public health and minimizing criminal profits. Control the supply. Remove the criminal incentive. Clean it up and carefully release it while working long-term to curb the demand.

Remember what Einstein said. “Insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results.”

In the meantime, keep firing war-on-drugs bullets at the heads of low-life, black-market crack, meth, and street-grade fentanyl dealers.